Select language:

Vitaly Komar: Between Synthesis and Eclecticism

 /  / Russkiy Mir Foundation / Publications / Vitaly Komar: Between Synthesis and Eclecticism

Vitaly Komar: Between Synthesis and Eclecticism


Artists Komar and Melamid were the most significant duo in the Era of Stagnation: they were hated (and secretly admired) in the Soviet Union and adored in the West; they invented Sots Art and were the visionaries behind the “Bulldozer Exhibition” in 1974. Vitaly Komar, former artist-slash-troublemaker, has lived in New York City for a long while, and without knowing his personal history, one could never take him for an immigrant.

Russkiy Mir continues the series of interviews with talented people who are living abroad and linked to the Russian or Russian-speaking culture.

Vitaly Komar

You once called yourself a conceptual eclecticist in an interview. Could you elaborate on that?

Conceptual eclecticism is the evolution of the early Sots Art, deliberately mirroring the mishmash of ideas in my head—and not only mine.

Conceptual eclecticism is when Iamong othersprofess love for very different styles of art at the same time, from Greek classics to medieval icons, from Renaissance to Impressionism, and so on. Just like laughter and tears, science and superstition, our consciousness is a cocktail of contradicting concepts, traditions and emotions. Long before Postmodernism, we stopped seeing the difference between synthesis and eclecticism.

Read also:

Terminology is a rather deceptive thing. Take the term avant-garde: it can be used in peculiar ways 100 years after its conception. The same can be said about underground art. Do you agree with that? And what should we do with those labels?

I can’t help but agree that today even cultured people can confuse the term avant-garde with Modernism or even Abstract art, the latter being, strictly speaking, not a style but a new genre. Avant-garde is about striving to shift established tastes. Different styles and movements can be avant-garde in different eras. For instance, in the period of late Gothic art, early Renaissance artists were avant-garde. I think that, taken in this context, its better to call our underground art postwar avant-garde, dating it to a specific stretch of history.

The Bulldozer Exhibition, 1974

How much of Sots Arts popularity can be attributed to you and Melamid exporting it to the West? Could everything turn out differently if you stayed in the Soviet Union?

The first people to popularize Sots Art were the members of the Soviet authorities who trashed our exhibition with bulldozers and destroyed many artworks in 1974, with the whole world watching. As for things turning out differently, that reminds me of another question: Would Bryullov paint The Last Day of Pompeii or would Gogol write Dead Souls if they didnt live and work in Rome? There are no ‘what-ifs in the past.

What event in the Soviet history would you interpret as an act of conceptual artor performance art?

The Soviet regime was based on ideology, which made the USSR a conceptual state. By late 1920s-early 1930s the Russian avant-garde was no longer the new governments official art; it was banished from the museums and into the streets. There, in the street, avant-garde endured in the eras established formsin red slogans of the agitprop and visual propaganda; in street demonstrations and celebratory performances on Red Square. As Mayakovsky once said, Streets are our brushes, squares our palettes!

I see those red rectangles with appeals-slash-incantations, those white texts with white exclamation points as innovations of the state conceptualism. That is, with Social Realism in museums and at exhibitions, the official art of Social Conceptualism co-reigned in the streets. It was that enduring branch of the Russian avant-garde that inspired our early Sots Art.

Sketch of the monument to the Bulldozer Exhibition, 2014

You have lived in the US most of your life. Do you think there is correlation between immigration waves and the art that newcomers have tried to bring to the American market?

There have always been talented youth in Russia. But for the last 25 years, new generations of Moscow artists are shaped by an environment close to South American capitalism. The traditions of romanticizing crime are pernicious. Their outbursts tend to rob artists of self-criticism, self-reflection and self-irony.

In that environment, to be patriotic means not to love ones nation and its traditions, but rather to be intolerant of other nations traditions. I cannot comprehend why such artists would seek success in the West. Why seek recognition from people whose tastes and opinions you have no respect for? Unlike those from the newer immigration waves, I still idealize the North American social model, with all its (and mine) weaknesses and strengths. Of course, the Western art market should be criticized, but, in todays world, there is still nothing better than that.

You would probably agree that Soviet symbols are fertile ground for art experimentation. Like in your project New Symbolism where the epoch didnt create its symbols, it was the other way round: symbols invented by artists functioned as some kind of simulacra. Can you imagine yourself living in another era and reflecting it, or do you consider the historical point of existence irrelevant?

When I was 13-15 years old, I loved reading yellowed pre-revolutionary magazines and I sometimes wished I could live among the people of the Silver Age. But every time I remembered how terrible their deaths were, my philosophizing cooled off.

I have a dream of making an exhibition of Russian artists from different eras, a small one, very dense from a conceptual point of view. I can knowingly select the works predating visual dualism and reflecting the dialectics of the Eastern and Western traditions. Some kind of conceptual eclecticism of the Eurasian art. It could be called The Origins of Russian Postmodernism. Art lovers across the world are aware of the origins of Nihilists or Russian avant-garde pioneers. However, nothing but the exhibition Im talking about can make the pioneers of the Russian Postmodernism known to the public.

Portrait of Ronald Reagan as a Centaur, 1980/81

Todays art is intellectualized to a fault; visuals are often less important than concepts. What are the reasons for that?

In Western galleries all extremes are welcome, be they visual or conceptual. Surely, every market has dictatorial ambitions, but if, say, wines from Australia or Slovenia are all the rage, it doesnt mean that the market made people give up beer or apple juice. Galleries differ, as do tastes. Be careful, though: if you need rare wine, you wont find it in a furniture store.


New publications

As the Russkiy Mir reported, residents of Papua New Guinea addressed the head of the Russian Orthodox Church with a collective petition to establish an Orthodox mission in their country. This proposal was put forward after Kirill Shrakbul, a priest and head of the ROC mission in Taiwan, had visited Papua New Guinea.
On September 1, millions of children in Russia went to school. And millions of their peers in Ukraine also went to schools. Everything seems to be the same: flowers, bows, well-dressed children, excited parents... And yet there is a difference and a very significant one: children in Russia go to schools to study in their native language. However, starting with this academic year, hundreds of thousands of Russian-speaking children no longer have this opportunity in Ukraine.
The opposition bloc won at the parliamentary elections held in Montenegro. Its position is considered pro-Serb and pro-Russian. Director of the Center for Contemporary Balkan Crisis Studies of the RAS Institute of Slavic Studies Dr. Elena Guskova believes that if the opposition succeeds in uniting efforts the country's foreign policy can seriously change.
The Russian school is usually criticized for endless reforms and the notorious unified national exam. However it provides a rather high-quality consistent classical education following legacy of the very Prussian gymnasium, which was the foundation for its predecessors, schools of the Russian Empire and the USSR, to grow upon. Thus, it is a potent soft power tool abroad. However, mere financial and licensing support to private Russian schools in other countries is insufficient for this soft power to be efficient.
75 years ago, the United States detonated nuclear weapons over the Japanese cities of Hiroshima and Nagasaki, and four years later the Soviet Union got its atomic weapons. 75 years ago, the most horrendous and destructive military action in the history of mankind took place. US dropped nuclear bombs on the Japanese cities of Hiroshima and Nagasaki.
As the new academic year starts, Russian teachers will travel to three new countries - Mongolia, Serbia and Uzbekistan. There are two more countries waiting for teachers from Russia according to the emerging tradition (Tajikistan since 2017 and Kyrgyzstan since 2019). For the first time, Vietnam requests Russian teachers to teach Russian in the remote mode. This is how the program for promoting Russian language abroad has been developing.
Russia has become the first country in the world to register a vaccine against coronavirus, but it seems that no one is happy about this. It is alleged that even before the third phase of clinical trials, Sputnik-V will be administered to millions of Russian citizens - in the coming month. It is reported that the new vaccine has many adverse reactions, but it allegedly provides few protective antibodies. Each of these theses is incorrect to one degree or another. However, this does not mean that the vaccine necessarily works. Let's try to figure out how things really are.
Nearly one hundred and fifty African students and teachers from Tanzania, Ruanda, Kenya, Zambia, Uganda, Madagascar and Mauritius participated in a 12-day intensive Russian language course in July. It marked the first stage of the Distant Russian in Africa online project aimed to strengthen humanitarian ties with Africa, which had been discussed at the 2019 Russia-Africa Summit in Sochi.